Hey there! As electric vehicles continue their meteoric sales growth, all-electric SUVs stand out as a particularly enticing green option for eco-conscious drivers. Blending utility, adventure and futuristic tech, these capable family EVs promise sustainable journeys on and off the beaten track.
But with models flooding the market, the choice can be confusing. As two major players unveil their debut electric SUVs, how do the 2023 Subaru Solterra and 2021 Hyundai Ioniq 5 compare? Which best suits your needs for a feature-packed yet affordable electric escape?
As an independent EV industry analyst, I‘ve undertaken a comprehensive side-by-side evaluation across over 15 key factors – from performance and charging to comfort and value. Read on for my detailed guide highlighting the pros, cons and ideal buyer for each zero-emissions SUV.
At A Glance: Key Spec Comparison
Before jumping into the nitty-gritty, let‘s briefly overview how the Solterra and Ioniq stacks up on paper across some of the most important metrics.
| Subaru Solterra | Hyundai Ioniq 5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Drive Type | AWD | FWD/RWD/AWD |
| Range (max) | 228 miles | 303 miles |
| Acceleration 0-60 mph | 6.5 seconds | 5.2 seconds |
| Charge Time (10-80%) | 56 minutes | 18 minutes |
| Ground Clearance | 8.3 inches | 6 inches |
| Cargo Capacity | 27.7 cu ft | 27.2 cu ft |
| Seating | 5 seats | 5 seats |
| Drive Assist Level | ADAS only | Level 2 |
| Base MSRP | $45,495 | $41,450 |
With class-leading range and rapid charging, the Ioniq 5 clearly impresses on paper. But specs only reveal part of the story. As we analyze both EVs in more depth across 15 key factors, a more nuanced picture emerges. Let‘s shift into gear and take a closer look!
Performance and Handling
If getting from A to B swiftly is a priority, the Ioniq 5 has a clear edge. The 320 horsepower AWD variant delivers sports car-like acceleration, sprinting from 0-60mph in just 5.2 seconds. Torque is also ample to power out of corners or tricky terrain.
Conversely, the Solterra‘s 215 horses result in slower straight-line pace at 6.5 seconds 0-60mph. However, the permanently available AWD helps regulate power distribution for optimized traction on loose or slippery surfaces.
So while the Ioniq 5 is objectively quicker, the Solterra has an ace up its sleeve for more extreme adventures.
Winner: Ioniq 5 for raw speed, Solterra for off-road mastery
Range and Charging
This is arguably the area where the Ioniq 5 dwarfs not just the Solterra, but the majority of affordable EVs.
Hyundai‘s advanced battery chemistry allows select RWD variants to squeeze out an incredible 303 miles from a single charge – 35% further than the Solterra‘s maximum 228 mile range.
Even base Ioniq 5 trims beat Subaru‘s efforts, offering 250+ mile ranges.
Charging is also blisteringly quick at supported stations. A 10-80% top up takes just 18 minutes – less than a third of the Solterra‘s 56 minute charging time.
However, the Solterra‘s 400V battery can replenish rapidly at more widespread chargers. Hyundai‘s 800V battery requires less common stations for its headline speeds.
So in terms of maximum potential, Hyundai clearly leads. But Subaru offers greater convenience and consistency.
Winner: Ioniq 5 for its stellar peak range numbers, Solterra for charging flexibility
Autonomous Driving & Safety
While fully self-driving EVs remain rare and expensive, Hyundai notably includes Level 2 autonomous capabilities with the Ioniq 5. This advanced system can independently handle steering, accelerating and braking in certain scenarios like traffic jams or highway cruising. This helps reduce driver burden and stress during mundane driving.
Conversely, Subaru focused more on bolstering safety through advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS). Lane keep assist, adaptive cruise control and collision alert all come standard. But relieving the human driver is not an option.
Ultimately it depends whether you prioritize avoiding accidents or reducing driving workload. The systems don‘t overlap much, so there‘s no clear superior option.
Winner: Tie. Get the Ioniq 5 for a taste of self-driving, or the Solterra if safety is paramount.
Off-Road Ability
This is an area where the Solterra‘s design really shines through. With a muscular body kit, 8.3 inches of ground clearance and grippy 20-inch wheels, Subaru‘s offering can better keep its composure when the going gets rough.
The Ioniq 5 makes do with only 6 inches of clearance. While the AWD variant has ample power to counter wheel slippage, its lower set suspension remains a liability on more challenging tracks. Of course, few owners will subject their EV to extreme rock crawling. But the Solterra certainly inspires more confidence.
Winner: Solterra for off-tarmac journeys. Stick to paved paths in the Ioniq 5.
Interior Space & Comfort
Both EVs guarantee comfy journeys, but the Ioniq 5 nudges ahead for spoiling passengers. Creative touches like reclining front seats with leg rests and a sliding center console bring first class luxury to the EV segment.
Combined with an airy, minimalist lounge-like layout centered around ambient lighting and sustainable materials, the Ioniq 5 makes road tripping a downright enjoyable experience – whether actively driving or charging.
That said, the Solterra also impresses with clever storage solutions and a cleverly packaged cabin allowing generous head and leg room for all passengers. But creature comforts are less stand out.
Winner: Ioniq 5 to pamper passengers. Solterra offers greater practicality.
Cargo Capacity
With passenger roominess covered already, what about packing your EVs for adventures? Here the stats are nearly identical on paper.
The Solterra offers 27.7 cubic feet of storage with the rear seats upright.
The Ioniq 5 comes in at 27.2 cubic feet by the same measure.
Both also allow folding down the 60/40 split-fold rear seats to accommodate bulkier items like camping gear or sports equipment.
In practice, the Solterra‘s boxier proportions may allow packing somewhat more irregularly shaped items. But ultimately there is little between them when it comes to carrying capability.
Winner: Tie. Both handle family-sized hauling needs.
Design & Styling
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but both these electric SUVs are handsome inside-out.
The Solterra channels Subaru‘s affinity for outdoorsiness through its tough exterior profile. Flared arches, splash guards and matte cladding give it a ready-for-adventure look.
Inside, eco-credentials inspire choices like High-Touch zones utilizing recycled plastics and bio-based materials. An enormous panoramic moonroof also keeps things light and airy.
Meanwhile, the Ioniq 5 merges retro 80s conceptual cues on its sleek exterior with a minimalist, technology-forward interior. Creative use of sustainable materials like eco-wool bio textiles and BTX-free paints reinforce its environmentally-conscious persona.
Winner: Subjective. Style alignment depends on personal taste. Both impress in their own way.
Technology & Connectivity
EVs herald a new era of technological possibility given their software-centric design. In terms of in-car tech, both pack 12+ inch touchscreens with smartphone mirroring as standard. The centrally mounted curved displays are responsive, intuitive and grant access to features like climate adjustments.
Unique to the Ioniq 5 is its Vehicle-to-Load (V2L) function that effectively turns the battery pack into a giant portable charger. This allows powering laptops, drones, camping lighting or even small appliances direct through exterior charging ports.
Connectivity and active safety technology like automated emergency braking are comparably matched. So the Ioniq 5‘s extended functionality through V2L is a niche but novel differentiator.
Winner: Ioniq 5. V2L expands usefulness beyond just driving.
Cost & Value Comparison
Affordability is key for mainstream EV adoption. So how do these electric SUVs compare on sticker prices after available savings?
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 slightly undercuts the Solterra on starting prices at $41,450 versus $45,495 MSRP respectively for their base trims.
However, both vehicles qualify for the full $7,500 federal tax credit along with additional state-level incentives.
When factoring potential discounts, there is negligible difference in terms of overall cost and value.
That said, Hyundai also offers cheaper mid-tier trims, reserving high-end configurations for its Limited model. Subaru‘s entire 3 trim range is closely stacked on pricing.
Winner: Tie. Strong value can be found across both lineups after savings.
The Verdict: Tailor Your Choice To Intended Use
So there we have it – a comprehensive feature-by-feature comparison guide between two of the hottest electric SUVs available. Ultimately there is no single clear winner – each vehicle shines in different scenarios.
For swift family transport with a touch of luxury, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 leads the pack. Its gorgeous interior, rapid charging and advanced driving assistance make daily commutes breezy while still promising adventurous weekends. Style-conscious suburbanites and tech lovers will also delight in its well-balanced blend of form and function.
Meanwhile the Subaru Solterra best serves off-grid explorers needing to go that extra mile, both figuratively and literally. Generous ground clearance, muscular styling and a focus on safety technologies make it at home on rougher terrain. Existing Subaru loyalists will also welcome its familiar durable build that now pairs eco-friendly power with practicality.
At the end of the day, aligning test drives and specifications to your priorities is key to determine the ideal electric SUV for your lifestyle. Hopefully breaking down the Solterra and Ioniq 5 across 15 factors provides clarity in making the right choice.
Have additional questions or want personalized advice on selecting an electric vehicle? Feel free to get in touch! I‘m always happy to chat EVs, tech and transportation trends with curious readers like yourself.
