I want to help you understand the key differences between scissor switch and mechanical keyboard mechanisms so you can decide which type best suits your needs and preferences. In this guide, I‘ll compare how these two major keyboard types perform and sound.
To Start, What Are We Comparing Here?
Scissor switch keyboards use a rubber membrane beneath keys and get their name from the crisscross scissor linkage that guides each key. When you press a key, the scissor mechanism collapses, allowing a rubber dome beneath to make contact. Scissor switches are known for quiet operation and low profiles.
In comparison, mechanical keyboards use real physical switches under each key that get triggered when you press down. Each keyswitch contains a spring and metallic contact system that registers your keypress. Mechanical keyboards are appreciated for their durability, customization potential, and tactile feel.
Now let‘s analyze some key factors in detail! I‘ll also share my expert recommendations at the end for choosing the best keyboard type for you.
Noise Levels – Mechanical Clack vs Scissor Switch Stealth
Scissor switches operate almost silently with noise levels around 30-40 dB which is comparable to very quiet ambient office noise. This stealthy acoustical profile makes them less disruptive in shared workspaces.
Mechanical keyboards span a spectrum – some loud clicky switches put out 55-60 dB noise which can be disruptive near coworkers. But many typists prefer the audible feedback. Quieter linear switches rated at 40-45 dB may better suit professional offices.
Here‘s a comparison of the volume levels:
| Keyboard Type | Noise Level (dB) | Real-Life Comparisons |
|---|---|---|
| Scissor Switch | 30-40 dB | whispering, quiet office ambience |
| Clicky Mechanical Switches | 55-60 dB | noise of normal conversation |
| Linear Mechanical Switches | 40-45 dB | quiet office ambience |
So in summary – scissor switches operate almost silently while mechanical keyboards cover a wide range from loud clicky to subtle linear switches. Choose clicky mechanical switches if you prefer audible feedback or scissor switches for minimal noise.
Ease of Use – Key Travel Differences
Scissor switch keyboards have very short key travel distances of 1-2.2mm. This allows you to type quickly with little movement needed to register a keystroke.
Mechanical keyboards demand more finger motion with key travel spanning 2 – 5+ mm depending on the switch. This longer travel distance results in a more pronounced typing feel. While this takes some getting used to, mechanical keyboards can enable faster, more precise typing accuracy once you adjust to the tactile response.
Maintenance and Longevity Metrics
When it comes to taking care of your keyboard, scissor switches need more specialized care while mechanical keyboards are designed for easy DIY maintenance.
Scissor switch keyboards have an average lifespan of 2-5 years before keys start to feel inconsistent or fail to register. And cleaning them requires targeted tools like air sprayers to remove debris stuck between keys.
In comparison, mechanical keyboards are built to handle decades of daily typing with an average lifespan of over 10 years thanks to durable switches rated for at least 50 million keystrokes. Removing and replacing individual keycaps and switches is simple for cleaning and maintenance.
| Keyboard Type | Switch Lifespan (keystrokes) | Average Keyboard Lifespan (years) | Maintenance Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scissor Switch | 10 million | 2-5 years | Difficult – air sprayers required |
| Mechanical | 50+ million | 10+ years | Easy – switches and keycaps detach |
Bottom Line Recommendations For You
If you prioritize: silence for not disturbing officemates, low force typing, minimal maintenance
→ Scissor switch keyboards check all the boxes!
If you prioritize: durable construction, tactile switches, easy DIY repairs, customization
→ Go with a high quality mechanical keyboard!
I suggest trying different keyboard switch types firsthand to get a personal feel for your preference around sound, tactility, and responsiveness. Consider where and how you primarily will use the keyboard when deciding between scissor and mechanical mechanisms.
I hope this comparison has helped you better understand the capabilities of each keyboard type. Let me know if you have any other questions!
