Retro mechanical keyboards are becoming more popular, with wireless connectivity and RGB lighting options. However, before you run out and buy one, it’s good to know their downsides too. These keyboards typically have different stroke lengths and are more sensitive than common membrane keyboards. Now, let‘s explore six reasons to avoid mechanical keyboards.
Retro Mechanical Keyboard Background
One type of mechanical keyboard seeing a resurgence is the retro keyboard. These take the unique feel of modern mechanical keyboards and package it into vintage-looking chassis. One modern feature you‘ll often find is wireless connectivity, though some even come with RGB lighting.
The most common type is the off-white and gray-colored keyboard iconic of the 1990s. However, some resemble even older vintage typewriters. It‘s hard to pinpoint when the retro trend emerged, but cheaper options in the last decade made mechanical keyboards more accessible to a new generation. From there, retro aesthetics became very popular, even among keyboard enthusiasts modernizing classics like the IBM Model M.
Reasons to Avoid a Retro Mechanical Keyboard
While some may prefer the retro aesthetic, mechanical keyboards have downsides too. Beyond their dated look, they also cost more, lack ergonomics and portability, generate noise, and their long keystrokes can bother some users. Let‘s explore these in more detail.
They Are More Expensive
The first reason to avoid a retro mechanical keyboard is cost. Keyboard prices have dropped over the years thanks to cheaper materials and manufacturing methods. However, mechanical keyboards‘ upgraded quality comes with a hefty price tag.
You can get a name-brand membrane keyboard for under $50, but rarely a name-brand mechanical keyboard under $100. Higher-end models cost significantly more. Membrane keyboards have fewer components, like plastic bodies, keycaps, rubber sheets, and membrane layers.
Mechanical keyboards utilize individual switches connected to a PCB and supported by a metal plate, increasing complexity and cost.
©Muhamad Aliyin/Shutterstock.com
They Are Less Ergonomic
Another downside of mechanical keyboards is ergonomics, especially if you type a lot. Some gamers also complain that mechanical keyboards don‘t provide the best feel. Beyond just comfort, the larger size makes adjusting them difficult compared to membrane keyboards‘ greater shape and style variety. If typing is important, an ergonomic keyboard is recommended.
They Are Bulky
The next reason to avoid mechanical keyboards is their bulk. Many occupy considerable desk space and are quite heavy, unlike 1990s keyboards that were heavier than most computers! While weight isn‘t an issue if the keyboard stays put, size is a problem for those going for a minimalist workspace design.
For example, the popular Keychron C2 mechanical keyboard is roughly 17 x 5 x 1.5 inches – smaller than older models but still bulky compared to modern slim options.
They Are Noisy
Another downside is noise. Clicky mechanical keyboard keys have been office ambiance for decades, letting everyone know you‘re hard at work. But most people no longer want to endure the loud noises. Some offices may frown upon mechanical keyboards.
If you use a loud keyboard at home, you may still grow tired of the constant clicking. Your options are disassembling the entire keyboard to manually install dampeners behind each key to reduce noise or simply getting a quieter membrane keyboard instead. Gamers should especially note mechanical keyboard noise will likely be heard on streams.
They Have Long Keystrokes
Keystroke refers to the distance keys must be pressed before activating. Mechanical keyboards are very sensitive but have a long total stroke length to bottom out. Whether you like long strokes is personal preference, but those used to short membrane strokes may find mechanical keyboards uncomfortable.
They Have Archaic Looks
What sets retro mechanical keyboards apart is their dated aesthetics, resembling the white/grey plastic of yesteryear. They deliver major nostalgia but likely won‘t fit a modern workspace.
Many also lack modern features like RGB backlighting to maintain their old-school vibe. So if you want the latest features, it‘s best to skip buying a retro mechanical keyboard.
Retro Mechanical Keyboard Alternatives
If retro mechanical keyboards don‘t seem right for you, consider these modern alternatives:
Sleek and Stylish: Apple Magic Keyboard
Apple Magic Keyboard (Wireless, Rechargable) – US English – White
$99.00 Wireless connection via BluetoothCompatible with Mac, iPad, iPhoneComfortable and precise typing experienceLong-lasting, rechargeable internal batteryWoven USB-C to Lightning Cable for charging
Apple is renowned for its well-designed, high-quality products. While compact, Apple‘s Magic Keyboard also comes in larger versions offering that signature MacBook keyboard feel for your desktop. As a membrane keyboard with short key travel, it‘s a sleek, comfortable pick.
Modern Gaming: ASUS ROG Falchion
ASUS ROG Falchion NX 65% Wireless RGB
$149.99 65% keyboard layoutUp to 450 hours of battery lifeRGB lightingPBT doubleshot keycapsIncludes polycarbonate keyboard cover
If you want a modern mechanical keyboard, check out the ASUS ROG Falchion NX. Though pricey, its compact 65% layout and RGB lighting make it a great gamer pick. The included polycarbonate cover also makes it easy to transport.
More Ergonomic: Microsoft Surface Ergonomic Keyboard
Microsoft Surface Ergonomic Kybrd SC Bluetooth English US Hdwr Gray
78-key keyboardDimensions are 19.68 x 10.51 x 1.65 inchesSupports Bluetooth 4.0/4.1Suede-like wrist restTwo preinstalled AAA batteries
If comfort is key, consider the Microsoft Surface Ergonomic Keyboard. As a split membrane keyboard with wrist rest, it ensures good ergonomics and has a uniquely sleek look.
Summary Table
| Reason | Description |
|---|---|
| They Are More Expensive | Retro mechanical keyboards cost more than membrane keyboards due to individual switches/metal plates. |
| They Are Less Ergonomic | Larger size and rigid structure makes mechanical keyboards less comfortable/adjustable than contoured membrane options. |
| They Are Bulky | Heavier than modern slim keyboards; takes up more desk space. Not ideal for portability. |
| They Are Noisy | Clicking sound can be disruptive without dampeners. |
| They Have Long Keystrokes | Stroke length longer than membrane keyboards, uncomfortable for some. |
| They Have Archaic Looks | Dated, nostalgic aesthetics may not suit a modern minimalist workspace. Often lack RGB, etc. |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are mechanical keyboards wired or wireless?
Mechanical keyboards come in both wired and wireless options.
What type of keyboards do laptops use?
Laptops use a membrane keyboard because space is a priority. However, laptop keyboards have a very short key travel compared to standalone membrane keyboards.
Are older mechanical keyboards different than modern ones?
Yes, while the underlying components are the same, older keyboards were much more rigid due to thicker plastic and metal components. Older keyboards also used inferior DIN or Mini-DIN connectors.
Why is an ergonomic keyboard better?
An ergonomic keyboard keeps your hands and arms in a more natural position with wrist support and contoured shape to properly align with your hands. This helps prevent repetitive strain injuries like carpal tunnel syndrome.
What is key rollover?
Key rollover refers to how many keys can be pressed simultaneously and still be recognized. Older keyboards had very limited rollover, but 10-key became standard. Now N-key rollover allows pressing all keys at once.
In summary, while retro mechanical keyboards are trendy, they have significant downsides worth considering before purchasing. Modern membrane and mechanical alternatives provide better ergonomics, portability, and aesthetics without sacrificing quality. Carefully weigh the pros and cons to make the right choice for your needs.
