GoPro has cemented itself as the leader in action cameras thanks to iconic models like the Hero 8 Black and Hero 9 Black. But with the Hero 9 released back in 2020 and several newer models now available, is it still a good option compared to the Hero 8 from 2019?
This in-depth guide compares the GoPro Hero 8 vs. Hero 9 across all the specs and features that matter most to help you decide which older GoPro suits your needs in 2023.
Introduction to the Hero 8 and Hero 9
The Hero 8 Black was launched in October 2019 as a major redesign from previous GoPro action cams. It featured improved HyperSmooth 2.0 stabilization, built-in mounting fingers, and useable 4K 60fps video.
The Hero 9 Black then arrived in September 2020 with some incremental upgrades, including:
- A boost to 5K video recording
- Larger rear touch display with preview mode
- Color front display for vlogging
- Bigger battery for 30% longer recording times
- Higher resolution 20MP sensor vs. 12MP on the Hero 8
In terms of physical design, the Hero 9 is slightly taller and heavier at 158 grams vs. 126 grams for the Hero 8. Both feature rugged, waterproof bodies perfect for mounting on helmets, vehicles or gear.
Design & Build Quality
The Hero 8 measures 66.3 x 48.6 x 28.4 mm (2.6 x 1.9 x 1.1 in), making it the more compact and portable option. It also slips into pockets easier thanks to its smoother contours.
The Hero 9 is bigger at 71 x 55 x 33.6 mm (2.8 x 2.2 x 1.3 in) but shares the same tough construction as the Hero 8 with rubberized sides for grip. Despite its larger battery, the Hero 9 is still lightweight enough for all-day action capturing.
Both models lack removable lenses but have durable glass lens covers to withstand scratches and impacts. They also share an IP68 waterproof rating allowing submersion down to 33 ft (10m) without a case.
The Hero 9 sets itself apart with a new front-facing full color display that can be used as a live preview monitor. This is useful when vlogging or taking selfies. The Hero 8 only has a small monochrome status display up front.
Image & Video Quality
A key upgrade on the GoPro Hero 9 Black is its higher resolution 23.6MP sensor, a big jump up from 12MP on the last-gen Hero 8. This allows 5K video recording at 30 fps along with 14.7MP image captures.
But the Hero 8 is no slouch, shooting crisp 4K UHD footage at 60 fps (twice the frame rate of the Hero 9 at this resolution). Its 12MP still photos still look decent for sharing online or small prints.
Both cameras have excellent image stabilization, but HyperSmooth 3.0 on the Hero 9 Black has slightly better performance thanks to an expanded horizon lock. Slow-mo lovers can shoot fluid 1080p video at 240 fps on either model.
Battery Life
The GoPro Hero 9 Black packs in a heftier 1720mAh rechargeable battery, beating the 1220mAh battery in the Hero 8. As a result, you get over 30% more recording time on a single charge – up to 100 minutes when shooting in 1080p.
In terms of battery efficiency, the Hero 9 does generate more heat when used for 5K/30fps recording or live streaming. Some users have experienced overheating shutdowns during very long 5K clips. The Hero 8 doesn’t suffer the same heating issues.
Connectivity & Software
Both of these GoPro cameras feature 5GHz Wi-Fi for quick transfer speeds plus Bluetooth for connecting external accessories like remote controls or external mics.
They work with the GoPro mobile app for remote monitoring, playback or camera settings adjustments. You can also wirelessly transfer photos to your phone automatically with the app.
GoPro refined their mobile app‘s interface for the Hero 9 release to simplify modes and settings. But the workflows are generally very similar across both generations.
Price & Value
As older generation models, the Hero 8 and Hero 9 offer great value by delivering good performance at lower prices:
- GoPro Hero 8 Black: $300 new or $150 – $200 used
- GoPro Hero 9 Black: $350 new or $200 -$250 used
The Hero 9 costs a bit more but packs extra resolution and battery life. Either pick represents a nice discount from the latest Hero 11 Black priced at $500. Both make for budget-friendly entries into GoPro’s action camera ecosystem if bought second-hand online.
Conclusion & Recommendation
For most consumer needs, I recommend going with the GoPro Hero 9 Black as the better overall choice in 2023. The upgrades in 5K video, bigger battery, high-res primary screen and front color display make it a more fully-featured option worth spending a little extra.
But the Hero 8 Black remains a great value pick if found at the right discounted price. It‘s lighter, more pocketable, and offers flexibility in accessories thanks to a more standard form factor shared with older GoPro generations. Stabilized 4K60 video and 12MP photo quality still hold up nicely for amateur and casual use.
At the end of the day, both older camera models are very capable of capturing stunning action footage and memories. I hope this GoPro Hero 8 vs. Hero 9 comparison helps steer you toward the best GoPro for your budget and needs.
