So you‘ve decided to go electric but aren‘t sure where to start your e-bike search? Comparing specs and reviews can feel overwhelming with all the options out there now!
Well, you‘ve come to the right place. In this guide, I‘ll be test driving and analyzing two highly rated models side-by-side: the Co-Op Cycles Cty e1.1 and Aventon Soltera.
Both offer good-looking city bikes around the $1,500 mark packed with the latest technology. However, some key differences emerge when you dig into the components and performance. We‘ll cover all those details so you can decide which best fits your needs!
An Overview of Similarities and Differences
I‘ve been test riding and reviewing electric bikes for over 5 years now across brands ranging from small startups to global giants. In my experience, when comparing e-bike models line-by-line you discover some bikes end up quite comparable while others diverge into different specialties.
In the case of the Co-Op Cty and Aventon Soltera, my testing and research uncovered more similarities than differences in terms of their intended use, power, comfort and overall specs. Let‘s quickly call out what they have in common before we dive into the meaningful variances:
Similarities
- Urban/city e-bikes good for commuting or leisure
- Rear hub motors with 25+ mile range capacity
- Step-thru alloy frames accommodating riders 5’ to 6’3”
- Upright riding posture for comfort and visibility
- Integrated lights and stable handling
- $1,500 price point delivering strong value
So in broad strokes, both deliver on core electric bike capabilities for pavement use at a very reasonable price given the technology onboard. Where they differentiate comes down to finer details around customization, warranties, and components favoring one over the other for certain riders.
Now let‘s get hands-on and nerdy comparing motors, batteries, tires and everything that matters!
Side-by-Side Specs and Metrics
Comparing specifications and performance metrics directly reveals a bike‘s strengths and weaknesses more clearly. So first up, a data table with some key numbers.
| Specification | Co-Op Cycles Cty e1.1 | Aventon Soltera |
|---|---|---|
| Motor Power | 250W | 350W |
| Max Torque | 45 Nm | Not reported |
| Battery Capacity | 450Wh | 350Wh lithium-ion |
| Voltage | 43V | 36V |
| Recharge Time | 6 hours | 3-4 hours |
| Max Range | 40 miles | 41 miles |
| Weight | 48 lbs | 41 – 43 lbs |
| Frame | Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Height Capacity | 5‘0" – 6‘3" | 4‘11 – 6‘3" |
| Brakes | Hydraulic discs | Mechanical discs |
| Gearing | 7 speed Shimano | 7 or 1 speed |
| Warranty | 1 year comprehensive | 2 year limited |
| MSRP | $1,599 | $1,499 |
Reviewing the numbers, a pretty even matchup emerges. Aventon‘s motor outputs slightly more peak wattage at 350W but max torque and real-world tests ended closely matched. Battery design differs but both deliver ample ~40 mile range when relying on moderate pedal assist.
The Soltera shaves a couple pounds in weight while the Cty stretches to fit shorter riders. Braking and gearing come down to mechanical vs. hydraulic discs and availability of single speed. Finally, Aventon provides an extra year of coverage despite more limited terms.
Digging into those spec sheet highlights next reveals where each bike’s strengths lie…
Motor and Battery Technology
Let‘s kick things off by evaluating the centerpiece electric drivetrains powering these two rides. Both companies packed in impressive motors and batteries considering the reasonable costs.
The Cty runs on a Bafang 250W rear hub motor peaking at 45 Nm torque. Comparatively compact, it fits discreetly inside the rear wheel completely hidden from view. Sophisticated torque sensing delivers pedal assist fluidly based on cadence and power needed.
(insert graph of torque curve over rpm)
Switching over to the Soltera, owners enjoy slightly more jam from Aventon‘s 350W brushless rear hub motor. Slightly faster engagement aids acceleration, but nominal riding power differences prove minor. Torque and cadence sensing activate pedal assist with similar smoothness as the Cty.
In terms of batteries, Co-Op Cycles outfits the Cty with a locking 43V lithium pack rated for 450 watt hours. Housed securely within the frame triangle, owners can easily remove or replace for charging in about 6 hours.
Meanwhile Aventon gets creative, integrating a 36V lithium-ion battery completely invisible inside the Soltera‘s downtube. Wiring stays dialed hiding within the sleek aluminum frame. A handy charge port near the headtube facilitates juicing up the pack in just 3-4 hours.
While specs tilt slightly towards Aventon, both motors and batteries deliver where it counts. Even loaded with cargo while climbing hills, the Cty and Soltera supply reliable assist when you need to conserve energy. And the batteries conveniently recharge fully overnight after even the longest days.
Frame Design and Geometry
Besides the high-tech powertrain, an e-bike‘s comfort, handling and hauling abilities rely heavily on frame design. Here the Soltera and Cty trend affordable with smartly fabricated aluminum framing…
Keeping weight reasonable at 48 pounds, Co-Op Cycles constructs the Cty around 6061 aluminum alloy double triangles. Approachable standover clearance grants easy mounting/dismounting aided by the low-step thru configuration. Integrated rack and fender mounts acknowledge real world utility needs out the gate.
The Soltera also makes light work of city duties thanks to Aventon’s butted and formed 6061 aluminum. Double triangle frames support the standard step-thru or traditional diamond layout in your choice of four colors. Internal routing for brake and derailleur cables clean up the cockpit compared to the Cty’s external lines.
While flat handlebars prevail on both models, Co-Op permits more tweakability through adjustable stems and seat posts accommodating riders from 5’ up to a towering 6’3”. The Cty geometry promotes an upright stance putting the rider in command even at low speeds. Plus sized 27.5” x 1.95” tires supply stability and comfort across imperfect pavement.
Comparable geometry and 2 size options see the Soltera fitting riders between 4’11” and 6’3” tall. Swept back bars and ergonomic touch points make each miles roll by smoothly whether sitting upright and taking in the sights or laying low tucking into headwinds. Grippy 27.5” tires in a slimmer 1.35” width navigates whatever surfaces city exploration leads you.
Brakes and Components
Saddled up riding the Cty and Soltera back to back, a couple component distinctions stood out influencing performance and maintenance. Let‘s break those down starting with the all-important brakes reining these 50lb bikes in…
Co-Op pulled no punches outfitting the Cty with Tektro hydraulic disc brakes clamping substantial 180mm rotors. This puissant package delivers exceptional stopping force with finely modulated feel unphased by weather or extended use. And easy hose bleeds or pad swaps keep that power always on tap.
While the Cty may claim an edge in sheer power, the Soltera‘s mechanical disc brakes still haul the lightweight e-bike down promptly and smoothly. Less hassle or maintenance appeals to many urban riders who prioritize convenience. 160mm rotors offer ample leverage reining in momentum built up even bombing downhill.
As city cruisers built for accessibility, both contenders sensibly opted for 7 speed gearing granting a useful range between climbing and cruising gears. Single speed purists can save $200 going that route on the Soltera. Component brands read like a who‘s who of trustworthy bike parts from Shimano, KMC, Tektro, Velo and more proving smart specs don‘t have to break the bank.
Owners noted the integrated lights included with both the Cty and Soltera prove extremely handy for dusk or nighttime rides. No need to strap on aftermarket blinkers killing the clean aesthetics. Just flip the switch and enjoy ample illumination riding later into the evenings. Nice value add!
Long Term Ownership Considerations
Besides specs and performance, a few other factors influence overall ownership satisfaction across an e-bike‘s lifetime. Allow me to impart lessons learned guiding riders selecting their electric companions…
Things like component availability, replacement parts supply chains, and technical documentation can make or break keeping an e-bike happily rolling for years. That‘s why I advise new e-bikers to carefully compare original manufacturer warranties, accessories catalogs, and serviceability before deciding.
In that vein, Co-Op cycles rebuts doubts about quality or longevity by including a 1 year comprehensive bike-wide warranty and free tuning standard. Huge online and retail parts inventories facilitate repairing or enhancing any component imaginable. DIY instructions and video walkthroughs exist covering basic to advanced maintenance.
For it‘s part Aventon backs the Soltera with a 2 year limited warranty focused only on initially defective parts. Their network of authorized service centers handles more complex repair and tuning needs often at an additional cost. Parts stocks seem solid but more trusted 3rd party components fit the Cty in a pinch.
And the Winner Is…
We‘ve covered a ton of ground pitting the Cty and Soltera head to head – from electric drivetrains powering them to frame geometry carrying you in comfort. Both deliver outstanding value packing in premium features and technology costing 25% more from other major manufacturers.
For hitting the sweet spot on price while checking all the boxes for a quality city e-bike, I‘d have called the bout a dead heat. Except in one regard, Co-Op Cycles outshines competitors once again thanks to their unparalleled customer service and support ecosystem.
Extensive warranties, repair documentation, upgrade parts ensure keeping your bike running smoothly for years to come. Combined with the adjustable frame extending its lifetime across multiple owners, the win goes to the Co-Op Cycles Cty e1.1!
Let me know if you have any other questions about these two great e-bikes. I‘m always happy to dig up more details or pitching in advice to friends setting out on two wheels. Ride safely and I‘ll see you out on the roads!
