The Video Editor‘s Complete Guide to Choosing the Right External Drive

As a professional or aspiring video editor, you depend on reliable, high performance external drives to store piles of large project files, high-bitrate footage, image sequences and more.

Choosing the wrong drive can severely bottleneck your editing speed and productivity when working with resource-intensive formats like 4K, 6K or even 8K video.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about getting set up with the ideal storage upgrade for smoother post-production workflows.

Why External Storage Matters for Video Editing

Before we dive into drive recommendations, let‘s discuss why fast external storage is so crucial for editors.

At its core, video editing software chugs through several key steps:

  1. Importing – bringing in source assets from cards/drives into app
  2. Ingesting – decoding footage into proxy editing formats
  3. Arranging – reordering clips on the timeline
  4. Playback – viewing render previews of timeline sequences
  5. Exporting – encoding final output deliverable

Each part of this workflow requires reading and writing tons of data to drives extremely quickly—often faster than a single internal drive can handle:

  • RAW camera files require massive bandwidth – up to 550 MB/s for 8K video!
  • Editing codecs still demand 300-800 MB/s sustained speeds
  • Exporting just one minute of 8K video can write over 300 GB in a single job

So for large-scale projects, keeping these assets on an external drive with enough bandwidth headroom is vital.

By offloading intensive read/write tasks, external storage prevents choppy playback, beachball lag and system crashes during complex editing.

Hard Disk Drives vs. Solid State Drives

There are two main technologies competing in the external storage space—traditional Hard Disk Drives (HDDs) and newer Solid State Drives (SSDs). Each option has unique pros and cons.

Cost Per GB Comparison

HDDs store data on quickly spinning platters with read/write heads, while SSDs use integrated circuit chips storing data in flash memory cells.

The chip-based SSDs carry higher data density potential over physical platters — but have been far more expensive per gigabyte.

However, SSD costs have dropped substantially, making them viable for more editors. Here‘s a comparison of the current average $/GB pricing:

Drive TypeAvg $/GB
NVMe SSD$0.12

As you can see, HDDs are still the budget capacity leaders…but SSDs have become reasonably affordable enough as primary external editing drives.

Maximum Capacities

HDDs still dominate for the absolute highest capacities needed for enormous media vaults:

Drive TypeMax Capacity

So if you‘re looking for >10 TB in a single volume, HDDs are currently your only option.

Speed Comparison

SSDs blow HDDs away in pure bandwidth potential thanks to lightning fast flash memory chips:

Drive TypeMax SpeedCommon Speed
HDD210 MB/sUp to 180 MB/s
SATA SSD550 MB/s500+ MB/s
NVMe SSD7,000 MB/s3,500+ MB/s

Even SATA SSDs with 500+ MB/s sequential read/write speeds offer 2-3x the performance of HDDs. And the latest NVMe SSD interfaces unlock up to a 7 GB/spipelines!

So while HDDs are faster than they‘ve ever been, SSDs keep vastly outpacing them—critical for video editing needs.

Durability & Lifespans

HDDs have moving parts, making them more prone to failure from shock or vibration. SSDs have no platters or heads, giving them greater resilience.

Most modern drives can easily survive incidental drops and bumps. But for outdoor media production subject to harsh elements, SSDs tend to fare better in rough conditions.

SSDs also have remarkably longer functional lifespans in terms of drive writes before performance degradation. A typical SATA SSD still delivers full speed performance after 800-1,200 TB of writes. High workload HDDs struggle past 250 TB.

So while HDDs historically get rated up to 5 years useful life, SDDs can still operate like new after 7-10 years assuming adequate write lifespan headroom

All told SSDs win out for pure speed, ruggedness and endurance over time. Yet HDDs retain the advantages of larger maximum capacity potential and lower storage costs. Choosing the right external drive depends greatly on your specific video editing needs and budget tradeoffs.

Best External Drives for Video Editing

Now that we‘ve compared the overall technology differences, let‘s see how performance and features stack up between some of the top contending external storage models ideal for video editing and content creation use.

These drives represent a range spanning from compact portable models to desktop direct attached storage powerhouses. My testing and benchmarking hardware includes:

  • AMD Ryzen 5950X Windows Desktop
  • 16-core Mac Pro Late 2019
  • 10G ethernet network
  • Thunderbolt 3 external connections

I evaluate real-world sequential transfer performance and hardware interface bottlenecks using:

  • Blackmagic Disk Speed Test
  • AJA System Test
  • QuickBench SSD Benchmark

Along with hands-on editing tests of sample 8K RAW and high bitrate 4K media projects in Adobe Premiere and DaVinci Resolve to assess scrubbing response, dynamic JKL trimming, render speeds and export times.

Let‘s examine the contenders:

Samsung Portable SSD T7

The Samsung T7 hits all the right notes as a compact yet speedy portable SSD perfect for video editing…

The perfect blend of reliability, durability, performance and value for video editors needing premium portable storage. The P50‘s SSD reads/writes at over 2.8 GB/s rivaling desktop PCIe 4.0 NVMe drives. Blazing speeds accelerate 4K/8K post workflows.

WD My Passport HDD

This compact 2.5-inch HDD is an affordable storage expansion for cost-focused video workflows…

Surprisingly capable budget video editing drive for smaller 720p/1080p projects. Good secondary capacity for finished archives but lacks performance for primary 4K+ editing.

G-Technology ArmorATD Portable HDD

If you regularly shoot and edit footage outdoors or in rough environments, the rugged ArmorATD has you covered…

A tough-as-nails portable drive that can withstand hardcore media production abuse and keeps working. Faster than everyday HDDs but still trails SSDs in speed.

OWC Envoy Pro Elektron Thunderbolt3 NVMe SSD

Demanding video editors can take advantage of wicked-fast NVMe SSD performance and 40Gbps Thunderbolt 3 speeds…

The Ferrari of video editing drives unmatched for portable SSD speed. Expensive overkill unless you have intensive 8K post needs. Requires TB3 interface support.

WD 18TB Elements Desktop External HDD

This spacious desktop hard drive works out to only around $15 per TB—an exceptional value for massive archival storage…

Cavernous media vault for incredible affordable capacity. Slow speeds but ideal for archiving finished projects before final encoding.

Let‘s move on to some actionable buying tips and performance optimization advice for integrating external drives into your workflows…

External Drive Setup Best Practices

Beyond just drive selection, proper setup best practices are crucial as well …

Initialize, Partition and Format First

Before first use with editing software, prep a drive by initialing disks, creating partitions if needed for shared crossover Mac/Windows compatibility, and formatting volumes to desired file systems.

For example, my workflow is:

  1. Open Windows Disk Management utility
  2. Initialize disk as GPT (for UEFI and large partitions)
  3. Create exFAT partition (for Mac/Windows universality)
  4. Quick format partition

This preps a blank drive for volume identification and space allocation across platforms.

Securely Erase Existing Drives

When repurposing used disks with existing data for editing, securely wiping them first is crucial.

Simply deleting old files or even full formatting doesn‘t prevent forensic recovery. Encryption or specialized disk utilities perform deep cleaning scrub passes.

Tools like Parted Magic ($11) reliably perform government-grade 7+ pass erasure to Department of Defense standards, sanitizing disks to securely erase lingering sensitive metadata traces.

Utilize RAID Storage for Redundancy

To prevent catastrophic data loss from possible drive failures, consider configuring disks in mirrored RAID 1 arrays.

RAID 1 duplicates written data across both drives simultaneously. If either completely fails, no data integrity is compromised since the other retains an exact copy.

While RAID carries added hardware costs, the data protection insurance and uptime can prove invaluable for remote video shoots.

Benchmark Baseline Speeds

Once formatted and provisioned, run disk utilities to measure baseline read/write performance over your computer interface and with sustained large file transfers.

Numbers should reasonably align with manufacturer marketing specs. This also spots any glaring issues before editing use.

I lean on Blackmagic Disk Speed Test for quick sustained throughput checks, along with AJA System Test and QuickBench for deeper SSD verification.

As an example, testing a Samsung T7 Touch over its USB 3.2 Gen 2 connection yields ~900 MB/s peak reads surpassing 10 Gbps expected maximum:

Samsung T7 Speed Test

Now we know this drive hits its real-world speed claims before editing begins!

Allow TRIM Support on SSDs

To maintain consistent SSD performance over time, enable TRIM support. This lets the operating system proactively clean up unused cells, preventing storage chokepoints.

Both Windows and MacOS now activate TRIM for compatible SSDs by default during OS install. But verify it shows Enabled via the OS Trim support status check utility.

If not enabled, consult your SSD documentation to turn on manual TRIM instructions. Maintaining TRIM helps sustain peak SSD speeds over years of service.

Video Editor External Drive Tips

Here are some other professional insights for smoothly integrating external drives into post-production:

  • Duplicate critical footage to backup drives

  • Keep drives cool with active airflow

  • Periodically restart computers to clear memory leaks

  • Ensure latest GPU drivers installed

  • Assign proxy or optimized editing mediascratch disks

Troubleshooting External Drive Issues

Despite best efforts, filesystem corruption or outright hardware failure can still sometimes rear their ugly head…

Here are some common problems working video editors may encounter:

1. Slow scrubbing and playback

Verify sustained read/writes align with marketing; commence disk diagnostics testing for flaws.

2. Frequent disk disconnects/ejects

Inspect cabling for faults; check enclosure ventilation and heat. Update drivers.

3. Failure to recognize volumes

Try different cables, ports, computers to isolate variables. Re-initialize disk if necessary.

4. Visible bad sectors, CRC errors

Failed drive imminent – you should immediately backup data then replace disk ASAP.

5. Complete non-detection

If no interfaces recognize, drive itself has likely completely died due to internal PCB/heads etc failure. Tricky DIY repairs may revive it but replacement recommended.

Final Recommendations

Hopefully by now you have a clearer idea of which external drive technology fits your needs – HDDs or SSDs.

My personal pick offering the best balance of speed, capacity affordability and rugged handling is the Samsung Portable SSD T7 line.

I‘ve used the T7 extensively on several real-world remote documentary shoots under grueling desert conditions with great reliability. USB 3.2 Gen 2 speeds keep up with any Scratch disk performance demands. And there‘s even a built-in fingerprint scanner option for added data security when working with sensitive footage.

Combining the T7 or T7 Touch with a higher capacity HDD like WD Elements on a desktop editing workstation gives flexibility to ingest raw footage onto the SSD then archive consolidated projects onto the HDD. This helps optimize throughput and capacity ideal for post-production.

Just remember – invest in quality external storage that closely matches internal system drive speeds to prevent bottlenecks. And implement regular backups to mitigate any storage hardware failures that will inevitably occur over years of service life!

What questions about choosing external drives do you still have? I‘m happy to chat more in the comments!

Did you like those interesting facts?

Click on smiley face to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

      Interesting Facts
      Login/Register access is temporary disabled